Vertical Integration in Healthcare

Definition

Consolidation of various stages of patient care and services under a single organization.

Key Critic

Mark Cuban

Associated Trend

Significant rise in recent years, shaping the future of U.S. health care, market consolidation.

Intended Benefits

Streamline operations, improve care coordination, potentially reduce costs, reduction in redundant services, enhanced data sharing, increased negotiating power for drug pricing, improved patient outcomes, enhanced patient satisfaction.

Criticism by Mark Cuban

Labeled as the 'original sin' of the US Healthcare System, causing lack of transparency and inflated costs, especially with PBMs.

Examples of Consolidation

Hospitals acquiring physician practices, insurance companies merging with healthcare providers, health systems developing their own supply chains, PBMs consolidating control over insurance, PBM services, and pharmacies.

Documented Challenges/Downsides

Reduced competition, higher prices for patients, limited provider choices, increased healthcare costs, adverse effects on patient health outcomes, pressures physicians to change referral patterns, potential for duplicate structures in the supply chain, lack of transparency.

2010

2018

2023

2024-09-16

How does vertical integration in healthcare impact patient care? Discover its benefits and long-term effects on treatment quality.

Vertical integration is touted as a pathway to enhanced efficiency and patient care but comes with its own set of challenges and complexities.

Web page about Vertical Integration in Healthcare sourced during research.

PLEXIS proudly announces the 2025 User Conference in Ashland, Oregon September 14th - 16th!Visit the PLEXIS 2025 User Conference page to learn more.

In recent years, the healthcare landscape has witnessed a significant trend – the rise of vertical integration. This phenomenon involves consolidating different stages of the healthcare supply chain, with entities like health insurance companies acquiring pharmacy benefit managers and hospitals absorbing independent medical practices.

Vertical integration in healthcare refers to the merging of different levels of the healthcare supply chain within a single organization. This can include hospitals, physician practices, insurance companies, pharmaceutical companies, and other healthcare providers. [...] The healthcare industry is undergoing significant transformation, driven by a quest for improved efficiency, reduced costs, and enhanced patient care. One of the key strategies emerging as a response to these challenges is vertical integration. This concept, which involves the consolidation of various stages of production or service provision within a single company, is reshaping how healthcare organizations operate. Vertical integration is touted as a pathway to enhanced efficiency and patient [...] As the healthcare industry continues to evolve, vertical integration is likely to play an increasingly prominent role. However, it is essential to approach vertical integration with a balanced perspective, recognizing both its potential benefits and its challenges. Policymakers, regulators, and healthcare leaders must work to ensure that integration efforts enhance competition, protect patient interests, and contribute to the overarching goal of a more efficient, equitable, and effective

In the case of healthcare, vertical integration theoretically promises improved coordination of care and more efficiently delivered, higher quality care. Consider the example of a hospital purchasing physician practices: it is reasonable to expect that when one entity oversees care across the outpatient and inpatient settings, information is transferred more efficiently and referrals are smoother, thus improving clinical outcomes. Particularly in the context of alternative payment models [...] As healthcare markets have become increasingly consolidated, the vertical integration of physician practices with hospital networks has drawn additional scrutiny. While vertical integration within healthcare was once predicted to improve efficiency and quality of healthcare delivery, empirical study has uncovered mixed results. In a review of existing literature, vertical integration has yielded inconsistent effects on health quality metrics, with modest improvements at best, but has [...] This concept, however, is being criticized because it could establish duplicate structures in the supply chain. Vertical integration in healthcare, where hospitals acquire physician practices, was elsewhere found to be counterproductive: In the US, the quality of care has not improved61 and, in some cases, has even worsened, despite increased costs.62 Similar effects are suggested from a cross-sector network of health, social, and community care providers in Hamburg-Billstedt, who have piloted

Improved Care Coordination: Vertical integration can promote better coordination of care. By integrating different levels of care—such as primary care, specialty care, and hospital services—healthcare providers can reduce medical errors, improve patient outcomes, and enhance overall patient satisfaction. [...] Reduction in Redundant Services: Vertical integration can minimize redundant services and tests, which are often a result of poor communication and coordination among independent providers. Enhanced Data Sharing: Integrated healthcare systems can facilitate better data sharing among providers. This can, in turn, improve decision-making and patient care, and facilitate the ability to track and manage population health more effectively. [...] Furthermore, the logic behind vertical integration is precisely the same as that behind value-based payment models. Healthcare policy experts often agree on little, but they are almost universally united in believing we should move toward these value-based payment models and away from fee-for-service reimbursement. As recently noted by a group of leading experts in a National Academy of Medicine publication:

Unlike large hospital mergers that are single, noticeable events, vertical integration happens incrementally. A hospital might acquire one physician practice this year, another the next, and so on, resulting in significant consolidation over time through small, individual transactions. Christopher Whaley Associate professor of health services, policy and practice [...] Skip to Main Content Date September 16, 2024 All News Share Facebook Twitter\_X Linkedin Email # Vertical integration is shaping the future of U.S. health care By Carl Dimitri With over half of America’s doctors now employed by large health systems rather than physician-owned practices, a team of Brown researchers is examining how this trend toward consolidation impacts health care costs, patient access and market competition. [...] “We’ve heard anecdotal evidence that vertical integration pressures physicians to change referral patterns, steering patients away from local facilities toward more expensive hospital settings, to essentially arbitrage that double payment rate and increase revenues,” Whaley said. “That’s really the type of behavior we wanted to look at in this study.” Professor Christopher Whaley (left) speaks at the launch of the Center for Advancing Health Policy through Research in 2023.